edubun
English
1 / 13

5 / 7 · Basic

Deflation and hyperinflation: dated cases

Prices that run away or fall year after year are rare, but each case in history shows how damaging the extremes are.

Jump to the 10 practice questions

You will learn

  • Hyperinflation (Cagan): over 50% in a month; 1.5^12 is about 130 times a year.
  • Germany 1923, Hungary 1946, Zimbabwe 2008: money printing to pay for government spending.
  • Deflation delays purchases and raises the real burden of debts; US 1929 to 1933 about −24%.

Before this: Why prices rise: demand, costs and money

1Explain

What counts as hyperinflation

There is no law of nature that separates high inflation from hyperinflation, but economists use a convention proposed by Phillip Cagan in 1956: hyperinflation begins in a month when prices rise by more than 50%. A monthly rate of 50% does not sound like much until it is compounded. Prices rising 50% every month are multiplied by 1.5 twelve times in a year, and 1.5 to the 12th power is 129.7. In a year, something that cost 1 unit costs about 130. A monthly rate of 50% is also equivalent to prices doubling in a bit under two months.

2Problem

Question 1

Prices rise 50% every month. By what factor do they multiply in 12 months, to the nearest whole number?

times

Solution

Answer: 130 times

1.5^12 = 129.7, about 130.

3Explain

Germany, 1923

After the First World War, Germany owed large reparations and ran a big budget deficit. The government paid its bills by printing marks. Before the war, in 1914, a US dollar cost about 4.2 marks. By November 1923 it cost about 4.2 trillion marks, a factor of one million million. Workers were paid more than once a day and rushed to spend the money before it lost value. People carried banknotes in wheelbarrows. Savings held in cash or fixed-value bonds were wiped out, while those who owed fixed sums were relieved of their debts. In November 1923 the government introduced a new currency, the Rentenmark, backed by land and industrial assets, and one Rentenmark was exchanged for one trillion old paper marks. The strict limit on how much was issued stopped the inflation within weeks.

4Problem

Question 2

The US CPI fell from about 17.1 (1929) to about 13.0 (1933). By roughly what percent did prices fall? (Whole number)

%

Solution

Answer: 24 %

(13.0 − 17.1) ÷ 17.1 = −0.24.

5Explain

Hungary, 1946, and Zimbabwe, 2008

The worst hyperinflation on record occurred in Hungary after the Second World War. Industrial output had collapsed, the country owed reparations, and the government financed itself by printing pengő notes. According to the study by Steve Hanke and Nicholas Krus (2012), at the peak in July 1946 prices were doubling about every 15 hours. The government introduced a new currency, the forint, in August 1946.

CaseYearsFactHow it ended
Germany1923About 4.2 trillion marks per US dollar in November 1923Rentenmark, November 1923
Hungary1946Prices doubled about every 15 hours at the July peakForint, August 1946
Zimbabwe2008 to 2009Monthly rate estimated above 79 billion % in November 2008Foreign currencies, April 2009

Read the rest in the full text

6Problem

Question 3

What common cause lies behind the German, Hungarian and Zimbabwean hyperinflations?
Solution

Answer: Governments financing spending by creating money

Money created faster than output pushes prices up and destroys trust in the currency.

7Problem

Question 4

Which economist named debt deflation?
Solution

Answer: Irving Fisher

Fisher described it in 1933.

8Explain

Deflation: the opposite problem

Falling prices sound like good news for shoppers, but a sustained general fall is dangerous for three reasons. First, if people expect lower prices tomorrow, they postpone purchases, which reduces demand, and firms cut output and jobs. Second, wages tend not to fall as easily as prices, so the real wage rises and firms lay off workers. Third, debts are fixed in money. When prices and incomes fall, the real burden of a loan rises, and borrowers cut spending or default. The American economist Irving Fisher called this debt deflation in 1933.

Read the rest in the full text

9Problem

Question 5

Disinflation differs from deflation because in disinflation…
Solution

Answer: prices still rise, only more slowly

The inflation rate is lower but still positive.

10Explain

Good and bad price falls, and why currencies fail

Not every falling price is deflation. The price of a television or a computer falls year after year because factories become more productive. That is a change in a relative price for one good. Deflation is a fall in the general level of prices, usually accompanied by weak demand. The difference matters: lower prices that come from better technology leave people richer, while a general price fall that comes from collapsing demand leaves them poorer and more indebted. Japan is a useful warning that even mild price declines can be hard to escape once people expect them.

Read the rest in the full text

11Practice

Practice set

The remaining questions of this unit, one at a time.

  1. In 1914 a US dollar cost about 4.2 marks and in November 1923 about 4.2 trillion. How many times more marks was it, in millions of millions? (Enter the factor in trillions, i.e. 1 trillion = 1)
    Answer

    1 trillion times 4.2 trillion ÷ 4.2 = 1 trillion.

  2. How did Germany end its 1923 hyperinflation?
    • A new currency, the Rentenmark, with strict limits on issue
    • Printing more marks
    • Banning all imports
    Answer

    A new currency, the Rentenmark, with strict limits on issue Stopping money creation, with a new currency, stopped the inflation.

  3. In July 1946, Hungary's prices were doubling about every…
    • 15 hours
    • 15 days
    • 15 months
    Answer

    15 hours Hanke and Krus (2012) estimate about 15 hours at the peak.

  4. Why can falling prices be harmful?
    • People postpone purchases and the real burden of debt grows
    • Wages always rise faster than prices
    • Shops stop selling
    Answer

    People postpone purchases and the real burden of debt grows Lower demand cuts output and jobs, and debts fixed in money become heavier.

  5. When did the Bank of Japan introduce a negative policy rate?
    • January 2016
    • March 1990
    • April 2009
    Answer

    January 2016 The −0.1% rate ran from January 2016 until March 2024.

12Practice

Review cards

HyperinflationBy Cagan's convention, prices rising more than 50% in a month
Germany 1923About 4.2 trillion marks per US dollar in November; Rentenmark ended it
Hungary 1946Prices doubled about every 15 hours at the peak (July)
Zimbabwe 2008100 trillion dollar note in January 2009; foreign currencies in April 2009
Debt deflationFalling prices raise the real burden of debts (Fisher, 1933)

13Summary

Key points

Key points
  • Hyperinflation (Cagan): over 50% in a month; 1.5^12 is about 130 times a year.
  • Germany 1923, Hungary 1946, Zimbabwe 2008: money printing to pay for government spending.
  • Deflation delays purchases and raises the real burden of debts; US 1929 to 1933 about −24%.
  • Japan: weak prices from the 1990s; negative rate from January 2016 to March 2024.

Next unitHow central banks respond
Full text · The whole lesson as one text

What counts as hyperinflation

There is no law of nature that separates high inflation from hyperinflation, but economists use a convention proposed by Phillip Cagan in 1956: hyperinflation begins in a month when prices rise by more than 50%. A monthly rate of 50% does not sound like much until it is compounded. Prices rising 50% every month are multiplied by 1.5 twelve times in a year, and 1.5 to the 12th power is 129.7. In a year, something that cost 1 unit costs about 130. A monthly rate of 50% is also equivalent to prices doubling in a bit under two months.

Germany, 1923

After the First World War, Germany owed large reparations and ran a big budget deficit. The government paid its bills by printing marks. Before the war, in 1914, a US dollar cost about 4.2 marks. By November 1923 it cost about 4.2 trillion marks, a factor of one million million. Workers were paid more than once a day and rushed to spend the money before it lost value. People carried banknotes in wheelbarrows. Savings held in cash or fixed-value bonds were wiped out, while those who owed fixed sums were relieved of their debts. In November 1923 the government introduced a new currency, the Rentenmark, backed by land and industrial assets, and one Rentenmark was exchanged for one trillion old paper marks. The strict limit on how much was issued stopped the inflation within weeks.

Hungary, 1946, and Zimbabwe, 2008

The worst hyperinflation on record occurred in Hungary after the Second World War. Industrial output had collapsed, the country owed reparations, and the government financed itself by printing pengő notes. According to the study by Steve Hanke and Nicholas Krus (2012), at the peak in July 1946 prices were doubling about every 15 hours. The government introduced a new currency, the forint, in August 1946.

Zimbabwe's hyperinflation came six decades later. Farm output and exports had collapsed after land seizures starting in 2000, and the central bank printed money to finance government spending. By November 2008 the monthly rate was estimated at more than 79 billion percent (Hanke and Krus). In January 2009 the Reserve Bank issued a note worth 100 trillion Zimbabwe dollars, which was barely enough for a few bus tickets. In April 2009 the government allowed foreign currencies, mainly the US dollar, to be used for all transactions and the Zimbabwe dollar was abandoned.

The cases share a pattern: a government that cannot raise taxes or borrow pays for its spending by creating money, people lose trust in the currency and spend it at once, and prices run ahead of the new money. It ends only when the money creation stops, often with a new currency.
CaseYearsFactHow it ended
Germany1923About 4.2 trillion marks per US dollar in November 1923Rentenmark, November 1923
Hungary1946Prices doubled about every 15 hours at the July peakForint, August 1946
Zimbabwe2008 to 2009Monthly rate estimated above 79 billion % in November 2008Foreign currencies, April 2009

Deflation: the opposite problem

Falling prices sound like good news for shoppers, but a sustained general fall is dangerous for three reasons. First, if people expect lower prices tomorrow, they postpone purchases, which reduces demand, and firms cut output and jobs. Second, wages tend not to fall as easily as prices, so the real wage rises and firms lay off workers. Third, debts are fixed in money. When prices and incomes fall, the real burden of a loan rises, and borrowers cut spending or default. The American economist Irving Fisher called this debt deflation in 1933.

The clearest case is the United States during the Great Depression. The US consumer price index fell from about 17.1 in 1929 to about 13.0 in 1933, a drop of roughly one quarter in four years, while unemployment rose to about a quarter of the labor force and thousands of banks failed. Japan offers a milder, longer example. After its asset price bubble burst in 1990, consumer prices were flat or drifting down for much of the late 1990s and 2000s. The Bank of Japan cut its policy rate to zero, then in January 2016 introduced a negative rate of −0.1%, and it did not end that policy until March 2024.

Good and bad price falls, and why currencies fail

Not every falling price is deflation. The price of a television or a computer falls year after year because factories become more productive. That is a change in a relative price for one good. Deflation is a fall in the general level of prices, usually accompanied by weak demand. The difference matters: lower prices that come from better technology leave people richer, while a general price fall that comes from collapsing demand leaves them poorer and more indebted. Japan is a useful warning that even mild price declines can be hard to escape once people expect them.

Hyperinflation destroys the three jobs of money. It stops working as a store of value because balances melt away, as a unit of account because prices are quoted in changing numbers, and as a medium of exchange because sellers refuse it. People then switch to a foreign currency or to barter. That is the reason Zimbabwe, which had the largest notes in the history of the modern world, ended by adopting foreign currency, and the reason the Rentenmark had to be strictly limited in quantity in 1923. A currency works only as long as people trust that it will keep its value.

Key points
  • Hyperinflation (Cagan): over 50% in a month; 1.5^12 is about 130 times a year.
  • Germany 1923, Hungary 1946, Zimbabwe 2008: money printing to pay for government spending.
  • Deflation delays purchases and raises the real burden of debts; US 1929 to 1933 about −24%.
  • Japan: weak prices from the 1990s; negative rate from January 2016 to March 2024.

Practice questions from Deflation and hyperinflation: dated cases on edubun

Embed this quiz

Free to embed. Please keep the credit line.

Sources for this course (16)
  • OpenStax, Principles of Economics 3e , openstax.org/books/principles-economics-3e: the inflation chapter (tracking inflation, price indexes and the basket of goods, how price changes affect different groups, costs of inflation, menu costs and shoe-leather costs)
  • the chapters on money and banking and on monetary policy (quantity theory MV = PY, central bank tools, inflation targeting, Volcker disinflation)
  • and the aggregate demand and supply chapter (demand-pull and cost-push inflation, 1970s oil shocks)
  • US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index handbook of methods and CPI-U annual averages 2021 270.970, 2022 292.655, 2023 304.702 on the 1982-84 = 100 base (bls.gov/cpi)
  • Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Federal Open Market Committee statement on longer-run goals and monetary policy strategy, 2% inflation measured by PCE since January 2012
  • federal funds target range 0 to 0.25% until March 2022 and 5.25 to 5.50% from July 2023 (federalreserve.gov)
  • 한국은행: 물가안정목표(중기 2%)
  • 기준금리 추이(2021년 8월 0.50%에서 2023년 1월 3.50%) (bok.or.kr)
  • 한국은행 경제교육 자료. 통계청(Statistics Korea) 소비자물가지수 2020 = 100, 연간 상승률 2022년 5.1%, 2023년 3.6%, 2024년 2.3% (kostat.go.kr)
  • 고용노동부 고시, 최저임금 2025년 10,030원, 2026년 10,320원 (moel.go.kr, minimumwage.go.kr)
  • US Social Security Administration, cost-of-living adjustment of 8.7% for 2023 (ssa.gov/cola)
  • Britannica entries on the German hyperinflation of 1923 (4.2 trillion marks per US dollar in November 1923, Rentenmark)
  • the Great Depression, and the 1970s oil crisis. Cagan, The Monetary Dynamics of Hyperinflation (1956)
  • 50% per month definition. Hanke and Krus, World Hyperinflations (Cato Institute working paper, 2012): Hungary 1946, Zimbabwe 2008. Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe 100 trillion dollar note (January 2009)
  • Bank of Japan, negative interest rate policy January 2016 to March 2024 (boj.or.jp)
  • All index sums, rates and compounding below were recomputed by hand and with a calculator script.

Checked: 2026-10-27