edubun
English

Pangaea and the evidence

Coal, which forms from swamp plants, has been found in Antarctica.

South America (green) and Africa (tan) today, from Natural Earth outlines. The bulge of Brazil faces the Gulf of Guinea across the Atlantic.

A map that looks like a puzzle

Look at a world map and the coasts on either side of the Atlantic seem to fit. People noticed early. USGS records that the Dutch mapmaker Abraham Ortelius suggested in 1596 that the Americas had been torn away from Europe and Africa, and in 1858 the geographer Antonio Snider-Pellegrini drew maps of the two continents fitted together and then separated. A fitting shape is only a hint, though. Coastlines change with sea level and erosion, and a good puzzle fit could be a coincidence.

BackgroundIn 1912 a 32-year-old German meteorologist, Alfred Wegener, published two articles proposing continental drift: around 200 million years ago a single supercontinent, which he called Pangaea, from the Greek for all lands, began to split apart. He collected evidence from many fields. Most scientists of the time believed continents and oceans were permanent, and his idea was badly received. The fatal weakness was the one his critics pressed hardest: what force could move continents? Wegener suggested they ploughed through the ocean floor, and the English geophysicist Harold Jeffreys argued, correctly, that solid rock could not do that without breaking up. Wegener kept gathering evidence for the rest of his life. He died in 1930 on an expedition across the Greenland ice cap, decades before ocean-floor exploration showed that he had been right about the movement and wrong about the mechanism.

Four kinds of evidence

The first is fossils. Wegener found identical fossil species of plants and animals on the matching coasts of South America and Africa, now separated by the Atlantic. He reasoned that most of these living things could not have swum or been carried across a wide ocean, and to him this was the most convincing evidence that the two continents had once been joined. The fossil fern Glossopteris is found in regions that are now near the poles, spread across the southern continents.

The second is rock. Unusual geological structures on one side of the Atlantic continue on the other, as if a page had been torn in two and the lines of print still matched. The third is past climate. Coal, which forms from lush swamp plants, has been found in Antarctica, so that frozen land must once have lain closer to the equator. And there are deposits left by glaciers in places that are now hot and dry, such as the Vaal River valley in South Africa. A single continent that later drifted apart explains these clues together.

The fourth kind came after Wegener: the ocean floor itself. Mirror-image magnetic stripes, young rock at the ridges and old rock near the trenches, and the deep earthquakes along sinking slabs gave the missing mechanism. Continents do not plough through the sea floor; they ride on plates that are made at ridges and destroyed at trenches. By the late 1960s these ideas had grown into the theory of plate tectonics. USGS dates the start of Pangaea's break-up to about 225 to 200 million years ago. Wegener's supporter Alexander Du Toit proposed that it first split into Laurasia in the north and Gondwanaland in the south, which then broke into today's continents.

  • 1596: Ortelius suggests the Americas were torn from Europe and Africa
  • 1858: Snider-Pellegrini maps the continents fitted together
  • 1912: Wegener publishes continental drift and Pangaea
  • 1930: Wegener dies on the Greenland ice cap
  • 1963: J. Tuzo Wilson proposes the hotspot idea for Hawaii
Pangaea"All lands": supercontinent that began breaking up about 225 to 200 million years ago
Alfred WegenerGerman meteorologist; continental drift, 1912
GlossopterisFossil fern found across the southern continents, including polar regions
Coal in AntarcticaSwamp plants once grew there: Antarctica was nearer the equator
Laurasia and GondwanalandNorthern and southern pieces of Pangaea (Du Toit)
  1. What does "Pangaea" mean?
    • All lands
    • Old ocean
    • Broken plate
    • Hot centre
  2. In what year did Wegener publish his idea?
  3. What was the main weakness of Wegener's theory?
    • No force to move the continents
    • No fossils
    • Coastlines did not fit
    • He was not a scientist
  4. Coal in Antarctica shows that Antarctica…
    • Was once nearer the equator
    • Has volcanoes
    • Is sinking
    • Was always frozen
  5. About when did Pangaea begin to break up, according to USGS?
    • About 225 to 200 million years ago
    • About 2 million years ago
    • About 4.6 billion years ago
    • About 10,000 years ago
  6. Which was Wegener's strongest evidence in his own view?
    • Identical fossils on matching coasts
    • GPS measurements
    • Magnetic stripes
    • Deep earthquakes
  7. Glacial deposits in the hot, dry Vaal River valley are evidence of…
    • A past climate that does not fit today's position
    • Recent ice ages only
    • Meteorite impacts
    • Volcanoes
  8. Order these events from earliest to latest.
  9. Which two landmasses did Du Toit say Pangaea split into first?
    • Laurasia and Gondwanaland
    • Africa and Asia
    • Europe and America
    • Arctic and Antarctic
Key points
  • Wegener (1912): Pangaea split apart; fossils, rocks and past climates fit.
  • Weakness: no mechanism; he died in 1930.
  • Ocean-floor evidence later gave the mechanism: plates made at ridges, destroyed at trenches.
  • Break-up began about 225 to 200 million years ago (Laurasia and Gondwanaland).
Sources for this course (13)
  • USGS This Dynamic Earth: Inside the Earth, Historical perspective, Understanding plate motions, Ring of Fire, Hotspots (pubs.usgs.gov/gip/dynamic/inside.html, historical.html, understanding.html, fire.html, hotspots.html)
  • USGS Earthquake Hazards Program, Shadow Zone (usgs.gov/media/images/shadowzonegif): no direct P waves 104° to 140°
  • USGS FAQ Where do earthquakes occur? (usgs.gov/faqs/where-do-earthquakes-occur): circum-Pacific belt about 81% of the largest earthquakes, Alpide belt about 17%
  • USGS FAQ How many active volcanoes are there on Earth? (usgs.gov/faqs/how-many-active-volcanoes-are-there-earth): about 1,350 potentially active, about 500 erupted in historical time
  • NOAA Ocean Exploration, What is the Ring of Fire? (oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/facts/rof.html): more than 450 volcanoes, nearly 40,250 km
  • NOAA Science On a Sphere, Earthquake Magnitude Perspective (sos.noaa.gov/catalog/datasets/earthquake-magnitude-perspective): most great earthquakes are megathrust events at convergent boundaries
  • British Geological Survey, Discovering Geology: What causes earthquakes? (bgs.ac.uk/discovering-geology/earth-hazards/earthquakes/what-causes-earthquakes/): crust 25 to 70 km under continents and 5 to 10 km under oceans, mantle to 2,890 km, about 15 major plates, slab pull, ridge push, elastic rebound (Reid, 1906)
  • IRIS, Seismic shadow zone animations (iris.edu/hq/inclass/animation/seismic_shadow_zone_basic_introduction)
  • Earle, Physical Geology 2e, 9.2 The temperature of Earth's interior (opentextbc.ca/geology/chapter/9-2-the-temperature-of-earths-interior/)
  • ESRF 2013, The Earth's centre is 1000 degrees hotter than previously thought (esrf.fr/news/general/Earth-Center-Hotter)
  • Lehmann 1936 extracts, Harvard EPS (courses.seas.harvard.edu/climate/eli/Courses/EPS281r/Sources/Inner-Core/Lehmann-1936-extracts+interpretation.pdf)
  • layer depths 660 km and 5,150 km from PREM (Dziewonski and Anderson 1981)
  • Coastline figure: Natural Earth 1:110m (public domain).

Checked: 2026-10-17